A Georgia man will spend 14 years behind bars for his involvement in trafficking methamphetamine to Nelson County between 2016 and 2017.

On Aug. 20 in Nelson Circuit Court Phillip Bennet, 52, of Atlanta, Georgia was sentenced in Nelson Circuit Court to 20 years with six suspended, leaving an active 14-year sentence for one count of enhanced distribution of methamphetamine. Bennet was sentenced to an additional 40 years with all 40 suspended for two counts of participation in racketeering.

Judge Michael Garrett considered the arguments of Nelson County Commonwealth’s Attorney Daniel Rutherford and Defense Attorney Anthony Martin, who for the most part agreed with each other, before deciding Bennet’s fate.

“I have to balance all the facts,” Garrett said. “The plague that meth is to these communities and the size of the operation. I have to balance that with what you have done since you’ve been caught, which did not go unnoticed.”

Rutherford told the judge before the sentencing while Bennet was heavily involved with more than 10 others to conspire together to get meth to Nelson and other areas of Central Virginia, Bennet was honest, helpful, and willing to cooperate with the commonwealth after being caught.

“When Bennet was charged, he was honest and took ownership,” Rutherford told the judge.

Rutherford asked Garrett to sentence Bennet to 80 years total on the distribution charge, with 64 suspended leaving an active sentence of 16 years. Rutherford asked for 20 years for each of the two racketeering charges with all suspended. Rutherford said, given Bennet’s age, for the remainder of the time he has, he will be monitored and has to be clean of all drugs and alcohol after being released. Rutherford went on to tell the judge, these racketeering and conspiracy cases are a unique set of cases the commonwealth has dealt with and although others involved may have been given a heavier active sentence, each case is unique.

“Sixteen years active is warranted in this case,” Rutherford said.

Martin told Garrett he agreed with a lot of what Rutherford stated and said he was grateful that the commonwealth took the mandatory minimum sentence of 20 years off the table. This was taken off due to a statue in Virginia, stating if the individual charged divulges sufficient evidence for the commonwealth to use and testifies for other cases if needed — which Bennet did — the mandatory minimum will no longer apply to the individual’s sentencing.

“Since he literally gave up everything, he met the requirement,” Rutherford said in a separate interview on Aug. 21.

Martin asked Garrett to consider Bennet’s age, the help he’s been for the past year and a half in assisting the commonwealth, and to consider his pending case in Wythe County on one elevated distribution charge.

“We don’t agree with 16 years,” Martin said.

Martin asked the judge to consider Bennet’s lack of criminal history in addition to his cooperation and argued for less of an active sentence as well as for whatever sentence given to be run concurrent with Bennet’s pending charges in Wythe County. Rutherford disagreed.

Garrett said he couldn’t run his sentence concurrent with Bennet’s case in Wythe County due to the status of it and that’s not something he would normally do anyway.

“It’s substantially under what you could have expected had you not cooperated,” Garrett told Bennet after sentencing.

According to a February news release from Rutherford, from March 2016 through November 2017, a slew of individuals distributed meth from Atlanta, Georgia and Charlotte, North Carolina all over Nelson County and other areas of Central Virginia. They would then wire money back to Bennet in Atlanta, where he would purchase more meth and the pattern would continue.

“At the height of the ring’s operation, one pound of Methamphetamine was trafficked every week into Central Virginia,” the release said.

Charles Anthony “Tony” Fitzgerald, one of the individuals involved with the meth ring and charged with racketeering and possession of a controlled substance, is set for sentencing Nov. 5.

Get weekly Nelson County news alerts

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Erin Conway covers Nelson County for The News & Advance. Reach her at (434) 385-5524.

Erin Conway covers Nelson County. Reach her at (434) 385-5524 or econway@newsadvance.com.

Load comments